What I don’t like about the whole ‘privilege’ movement is
that it focuses on bringing down the privileged rather than lifting up the disadvantaged. Admonishments to check your privilege are all
about orienting your thinking to the ways in which you had it easy rather than
all the obstacles you overcame through effort and ability. The privilege
movement obviates against people’s agency. It encourages the disadvantaged to
regard themselves as victims and inclines the advantaged to feel ashamed of and
not responsible for their achievements. In the social justice space it creates
a horribly toxic and bitter race to the bottom regarding who is the most oppressed.
Is Obama more or less privileged than Stella Young? Who cares! Bob Hawke
doubtless had mountains of privilege of all varieties but leveraged it to
benefit huge cross-sections of society because he remained committed to helping
the disadvantaged. He may well not have been so successful in that endeavour if
he hadn’t been privileged. What counts is whether you’re a good person doing
your best.
Comments
Post a Comment